Finite products and sums over types and sets #
We define products and sums over types and subsets of types, with no finiteness hypotheses.
All infinite products and sums are defined to be junk values (i.e. one or zero).
This approach is sometimes easier to use than Finset.sum
,
when issues arise with Finset
and Fintype
being data.
Main definitions #
We use the following variables:
α
,β
- types with no structure;s
,t
- setsM
,N
- additive or multiplicative commutative monoidsf
,g
- functions
Definitions in this file:
finsum f : M
: the sum off x
asx
ranges over the support off
, if it's finite. Zero otherwise.finprod f : M
: the product off x
asx
ranges over the multiplicative support off
, if it's finite. One otherwise.
Notation #
This notation works for functions f : p → M
, where p : Prop
, so the following works:
∑ᶠ i ∈ s, f i
, wheref : α → M
,s : Set α
: sum over the sets
;∑ᶠ n < 5, f n
, wheref : ℕ → M
: same asf 0 + f 1 + f 2 + f 3 + f 4
;∏ᶠ (n >= -2) (hn : n < 3), f n
, wheref : ℤ → M
: same asf (-2) * f (-1) * f 0 * f 1 * f 2
.
Implementation notes #
finsum
and finprod
is "yet another way of doing finite sums and products in Lean". However
experiments in the wild (e.g. with matroids) indicate that it is a helpful approach in settings
where the user is not interested in computability and wants to do reasoning without running into
typeclass diamonds caused by the constructive finiteness used in definitions such as Finset
and
Fintype
. By sticking solely to Set.Finite
we avoid these problems. We are aware that there are
other solutions but for beginner mathematicians this approach is easier in practice.
Another application is the construction of a partition of unity from a collection of “bump” function. In this case the finite set depends on the point and it's convenient to have a definition that does not mention the set explicitly.
The first arguments in all definitions and lemmas is the codomain of the function of the big
operator. This is necessary for the heuristic in @[to_additive]
.
See the documentation of to_additive.attr
for more information.
We did not add IsFinite (X : Type) : Prop
, because it is simply Nonempty (Fintype X)
.
Tags #
finsum, finprod, finite sum, finite product
Definition and relation to Finset.sum
and Finset.prod
#
Pretty printer defined by notation3
command.
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
∑ᶠ x, f x
is notation for finsum f
. It is the sum of f x
, where x
ranges over the
support of f
, if it's finite, zero otherwise. Taking the sum over multiple arguments or
conditions is possible, e.g. ∏ᶠ (x) (y), f x y
and ∏ᶠ (x) (h: x ∈ s), f x
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
∏ᶠ x, f x
is notation for finprod f
. It is the product of f x
, where x
ranges over the
multiplicative support of f
, if it's finite, one otherwise. Taking the product over multiple
arguments or conditions is possible, e.g. ∏ᶠ (x) (y), f x y
and ∏ᶠ (x) (h: x ∈ s), f x
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
Pretty printer defined by notation3
command.
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
To prove a property of a finite sum, it suffices to prove that the property is additive and holds on the summands.
To prove a property of a finite product, it suffices to prove that the property is multiplicative and holds on the factors.
The NoZeroSMulDivisors
makes sure that the result holds even when the support of f
is
infinite. For a more usual version assuming (support f).Finite
instead, see finsum_smul'
.
The NoZeroSMulDivisors
makes sure that the result holds even when the support of f
is
infinite. For a more usual version assuming (support f).Finite
instead, see smul_finsum'
.
Distributivity w.r.t. addition, subtraction, and (scalar) multiplication #
If the additive supports of f
and g
are finite, then the sum of f i + g i
equals the sum of f i
plus the sum of g i
.
If the multiplicative supports of f
and g
are finite, then the product of f i * g i
equals
the product of f i
multiplied by the product of g i
.
If the additive supports of f
and g
are finite, then the sum of f i - g i
equals the sum of f i
minus the sum of g i
.
If the multiplicative supports of f
and g
are finite, then the product of f i / g i
equals the product of f i
divided by the product of g i
.
A more general version of finsum_mem_add_distrib
that only requires s ∩ support f
and s ∩ support g
rather than s
to be finite.
A more general version of finprod_mem_mul_distrib
that only requires s ∩ mulSupport f
and
s ∩ mulSupport g
rather than s
to be finite.
The sum of the constant function 0
over any set equals 0
.
The product of the constant function 1
over any set equals 1
.
If a function f
equals 0
on a set s
, then the product of f i
over i ∈ s
equals 0
.
If a function f
equals 1
on a set s
, then the product of f i
over i ∈ s
equals 1
.
If the product of f i
over i ∈ s
is not equal to 0
, then there is some x ∈ s
such that f x ≠ 0
.
If the product of f i
over i ∈ s
is not equal to 1
, then there is some x ∈ s
such that
f x ≠ 1
.
Given a finite set s
, the sum of f i + g i
over i ∈ s
equals the sum of f i
over i ∈ s
plus the sum of g i
over i ∈ s
.
Given a finite set s
, the product of f i * g i
over i ∈ s
equals the product of f i
over i ∈ s
times the product of g i
over i ∈ s
.
See also finsum_smul
for a version that works even when the support of f
is not finite,
but with slightly stronger typeclass requirements.
See also smul_finsum
for a version that works even when the support of f
is not finite,
but with slightly stronger typeclass requirements.
A more general version of AddMonoidHom.map_finsum_mem
that requires
s ∩ support f
rather than s
to be finite.
A more general version of MonoidHom.map_finprod_mem
that requires s ∩ mulSupport f
rather
than s
to be finite.
Given an additive monoid homomorphism g : M →* N
and a function f : α → M
, the
value of g
at the sum of f i
over i ∈ s
equals the sum of g (f i)
over s
.
Given a monoid homomorphism g : M →* N
and a function f : α → M
, the value of g
at the
product of f i
over i ∈ s
equals the product of g (f i)
over s
.
Given a finite set s
, the sum of f i / g i
over i ∈ s
equals the sum of f i
over i ∈ s
minus the sum of g i
over i ∈ s
.
Given a finite set s
, the product of f i / g i
over i ∈ s
equals the product of f i
over i ∈ s
divided by the product of g i
over i ∈ s
.
∏ᶠ x ∈ s, f x
and set operations #
The sum of any function over an empty set is 0
.
The product of any function over an empty set is 1
.
A set s
is nonempty if the sum of some function over s
is not equal to 0
.
A set s
is nonempty if the product of some function over s
is not equal to 1
.
Given finite sets s
and t
, the sum of f i
over i ∈ s ∪ t
plus the sum of
f i
over i ∈ s ∩ t
equals the sum of f i
over i ∈ s
plus the sum of f i
over i ∈ t
.
Given finite sets s
and t
, the product of f i
over i ∈ s ∪ t
times the product of
f i
over i ∈ s ∩ t
equals the product of f i
over i ∈ s
times the product of f i
over i ∈ t
.
A more general version of finsum_mem_union_inter
that requires s ∩ support f
and
t ∩ support f
rather than s
and t
to be finite.
A more general version of finprod_mem_union_inter
that requires s ∩ mulSupport f
and
t ∩ mulSupport f
rather than s
and t
to be finite.
A more general version of finsum_mem_union
that requires s ∩ support f
and
t ∩ support f
rather than s
and t
to be finite.
A more general version of finprod_mem_union
that requires s ∩ mulSupport f
and
t ∩ mulSupport f
rather than s
and t
to be finite.
Given two finite disjoint sets s
and t
, the sum of f i
over i ∈ s ∪ t
equals
the sum of f i
over i ∈ s
plus the sum of f i
over i ∈ t
.
Given two finite disjoint sets s
and t
, the product of f i
over i ∈ s ∪ t
equals the
product of f i
over i ∈ s
times the product of f i
over i ∈ t
.
A more general version of finsum_mem_union'
that requires s ∩ support f
and
t ∩ support f
rather than s
and t
to be disjoint
A more general version of finprod_mem_union'
that requires s ∩ mulSupport f
and
t ∩ mulSupport f
rather than s
and t
to be disjoint
The sum of f i
over i ∈ {a}
equals f a
.
The product of f i
over i ∈ {a}
equals f a
.
A more general version of finsum_mem_insert
that requires s ∩ support f
rather
than s
to be finite.
A more general version of finprod_mem_insert
that requires s ∩ mulSupport f
rather than s
to be finite.
Given a finite set s
and an element a ∉ s
, the sum of f i
over i ∈ insert a s
equals f a
plus the sum of f i
over i ∈ s
.
Given a finite set s
and an element a ∉ s
, the product of f i
over i ∈ insert a s
equals
f a
times the product of f i
over i ∈ s
.
If f a = 0
when a ∉ s
, then the sum of f i
over i ∈ insert a s
equals the sum
of f i
over i ∈ s
.
If f a = 1
when a ∉ s
, then the product of f i
over i ∈ insert a s
equals the product of
f i
over i ∈ s
.
If the multiplicative support of f
is finite, then for every x
in the domain of f
, f x
divides finprod f
.
The sum of f i
over i ∈ {a, b}
, a ≠ b
, is equal to f a + f b
.
The product of f i
over i ∈ {a, b}
, a ≠ b
, is equal to f a * f b
.
The sum of f y
over y ∈ g '' s
equals the sum of f (g i)
over s
provided that
g
is injective on s ∩ support (f ∘ g)
.
The product of f y
over y ∈ g '' s
equals the product of f (g i)
over s
provided that g
is injective on s ∩ mulSupport (f ∘ g)
.
The sum of f y
over y ∈ g '' s
equals the sum of f (g i)
over s
provided that
g
is injective on s
.
The product of f y
over y ∈ g '' s
equals the product of f (g i)
over s
provided that
g
is injective on s
.
The sum of f y
over y ∈ Set.range g
equals the sum of f (g i)
over all i
provided that g
is injective on support (f ∘ g)
.
The product of f y
over y ∈ Set.range g
equals the product of f (g i)
over all i
provided that g
is injective on mulSupport (f ∘ g)
.
The sum of f y
over y ∈ Set.range g
equals the sum of f (g i)
over all i
provided that g
is injective.
The product of f y
over y ∈ Set.range g
equals the product of f (g i)
over all i
provided that g
is injective.
See also Finset.sum_bij
.
See also Finset.prod_bij
.
See finsum_comp
, Fintype.sum_bijective
and Finset.sum_bij
.
See finprod_comp
, Fintype.prod_bijective
and Finset.prod_bij
.
See also finsum_eq_of_bijective
, Fintype.sum_bijective
and Finset.sum_bij
.
See also finprod_eq_of_bijective
, Fintype.prod_bijective
and Finset.prod_bij
.
A more general version of finsum_mem_add_diff
that requires t ∩ support f
rather
than t
to be finite.
A more general version of finprod_mem_mul_diff
that requires t ∩ mulSupport f
rather than
t
to be finite.
Given a finite set t
and a subset s
of t
, the sum of f i
over i ∈ s
plus
the sum of f i
over t \ s
equals the sum of f i
over i ∈ t
.
Given a finite set t
and a subset s
of t
, the product of f i
over i ∈ s
times the product of f i
over t \ s
equals the product of f i
over i ∈ t
.
Given a family of pairwise disjoint finite sets t i
indexed by a finite type, the
sum of f a
over the union ⋃ i, t i
is equal to the sum over all indexes i
of the
sums of f a
over a ∈ t i
.
Given a family of pairwise disjoint finite sets t i
indexed by a finite type, the product of
f a
over the union ⋃ i, t i
is equal to the product over all indexes i
of the products of
f a
over a ∈ t i
.
Given a family of sets t : ι → Set α
, a finite set I
in the index type such that
all sets t i
, i ∈ I
, are finite, if all t i
, i ∈ I
, are pairwise disjoint, then the
sum of f a
over a ∈ ⋃ i ∈ I, t i
is equal to the sum over i ∈ I
of the sums of f a
over a ∈ t i
.
Given a family of sets t : ι → Set α
, a finite set I
in the index type such that all sets
t i
, i ∈ I
, are finite, if all t i
, i ∈ I
, are pairwise disjoint, then the product of f a
over a ∈ ⋃ i ∈ I, t i
is equal to the product over i ∈ I
of the products of f a
over
a ∈ t i
.
If t
is a finite set of pairwise disjoint finite sets, then the sum of f a
over
a ∈ ⋃₀ t
is the sum over s ∈ t
of the sums of f a
over a ∈ s
.
If t
is a finite set of pairwise disjoint finite sets, then the product of f a
over a ∈ ⋃₀ t
is the product over s ∈ t
of the products of f a
over a ∈ s
.
If s : Set α
and t : Set β
are finite sets, then summing over s
commutes with
summing over t
.
If s : Set α
and t : Set β
are finite sets, then taking the product over s
commutes with
taking the product over t
.
To prove a property of a finite sum, it suffices to prove that the property is additive and holds on summands.
To prove a property of a finite product, it suffices to prove that the property is multiplicative and holds on factors.
Note that b ∈ (s.filter (fun ab => Prod.fst ab = a)).image Prod.snd
iff (a, b) ∈ s
so
we can simplify the right hand side of this lemma. However the form stated here is more
useful for iterating this lemma, e.g., if we have f : α × β × γ → M
.
Note that b ∈ (s.filter (fun ab => Prod.fst ab = a)).image Prod.snd
iff (a, b) ∈ s
so
we can simplify the right hand side of this lemma. However the form stated here is more useful for
iterating this lemma, e.g., if we have f : α × β × γ → M
.
See also finsum_mem_finset_product'
.
See also finprod_mem_finset_product'
.